on 11/17/2009
Why do I have to choose between these two awful comic book movies?
on 11/18/2009
Can I pass here?
on 12/24/2009
They were both awful, but Spidey 3 was by far less awful.
on 12/27/2009
Both were slightly misguided--Spider-Man 3 far more so--but Hulk was a stronger movie and more in-keeping with the character.
on 2/6/2010
Spider-Man 3 was pretty convoluted and ridiculous at times (to be expected in a comic book film, but even more than usual here) and is far and away the weak link in that trilogy. But it is still a far, far superior film than Hulk was. My favorite aspect of Hulk is how Ang Lee often paneled the screen, giving the movie a comic book feel, but that's not enough to give it the win here.
on 4/13/2010
Hulk was boring and pretty bad. But it doesn't even come close to the level of suck found in Spider-Man 3.
on 4/14/2010
I can't believe I'm picking Hulk over Spiderman but Spiderman 3 was pathetic.
on 7/15/2010
Easy choice picking the Hulk
on 9/23/2010
Both were disappointing, but Spider-Man 3 far less so
on 10/28/2010
I (mostly) liked "Spider-Man 3." I could've done without The Sandman being shoehorned into Uncle Ben's story, and I'd have preferred a better payoff for Harry Osborne, but at least I could actually see what was happening, unlike half of "Hulk."
on 8/3/2011
Ang Lee's Hulk is definitely the most (and possibly only) underrated and misunderstood of the Marvel films. It's far from perfect, but it's still better than Sam Raimi's efforts to conclude the Spider-man trilogy.
on 8/3/2011
Hulk sucks big green balls.
on 8/3/2011
Dont even get me started on the Hulk movie
on 11/27/2011
hulk all the way
on 1/28/2012
Hulk is not great, but in no way is it Spider-Man 3 bad. Not even close.
on 1/28/2012
That was a pathetic little comment. Hulk's biggest problem is that it is too long, and does bore in spots. But it's got that great, unique editing, some good casting, and a couple of decent action sequences. Spider-Man 3 is not without it's moments, either; for the most part, I liked Sandman, and Harry becoming the Hobgoblin, but they were crammed into a movie with too many villains, and Venom suffered more than the rest. And the fact that they screwed up Venom so completely makes Spider-Man 3 - an otherwise "decent" movie - lose major, major points with me.
on 12/20/2012
Hulk is one of those movies you appreciate more after the fact One of those you look back on and say "Oh I get it". That doesn't happen with Spiderman 3. Spiderman 3 is just bad.
on 8/25/2013
at least hulk was trying to give us a complicated look at Bruce banner and sure it didn't go to well and the film was boring and had laughable affects but it was still better then spider man 3
on 1/14/2015
Yes, Hulk WAS 'THAT' bad. Spider-Man 3 looks like a good movie in comparison. Hulk was a boring, boring drama. A BAD boring, boring drama.
on 1/14/2015
"at least hulk was trying to give us a complicated look at Bruce banner" --- "One of those you look back on and say "Oh I get it."" --- "underrated and misunderstood" :( You're all knucking futs.
on 1/15/2015
Both Suck but Hulk was just hard to get through
on 1/15/2015
No winners here...
on 4/5/2015
I think Hulk is quite underrated. So I'll choose it.
on 10/14/2015
Ooooh tough one. I guess Spider-Man 3 would win simply because I remember it better. Sure it has some utter tripe in it, but I can remember enough good stuff (Sandman effects, a couple of decent action sequences etc) to make it at least worth watching in the background on TV when I have nothing to do. Conversely, I remember NOTHING from Hulk, so Spider-Man 3 wins for now.
on 4/8/2020
Probably Hulk.
on 4/8/2020
Spider-Man 3 is better than the dumbs dumbs can admit. Far better than Ang Lee's poop shoot.
on 4/9/2020
Spidey 3, not even close. Eric Bana is terrific as an actor, too bad they put him in such a lackluster film as Ang Lee's coma of a superhero film.
on 7/19/2020
Hulk had some good stuff, SM3 is just garbage.
on 7/20/2020
Two waste bad forgotten beyond from the era, hulk is more disapproving waste of lack of crap plot.
on 2/13/2021
both sucked but SM3 sucked more
on 10/27/2022
Spider-Man 3 is disappointing and the worst Spider-Man movie but at least it isn't Hulk 2003 level terrible
on 11/27/2022
Neither are great but i'm picking Spider-Man 3 based on Thomas Haden Church's performance and the scene where he turns into Sandman is actually pretty neat.
